From 4d906f78569548b30f1be711fb2970d31626d53d Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Max Lobur Date: Wed, 10 Feb 2016 13:04:31 +0200 Subject: [PATCH] Add multi-image-deployment spec Change-Id: I49bb741b581e8aea733ff521a8fe0ad0a42a6ace --- specs/multi-image-deployment.rst | 199 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 1 file changed, 199 insertions(+) create mode 100644 specs/multi-image-deployment.rst diff --git a/specs/multi-image-deployment.rst b/specs/multi-image-deployment.rst new file mode 100644 index 0000000..f2bcf4d --- /dev/null +++ b/specs/multi-image-deployment.rst @@ -0,0 +1,199 @@ +.. + +This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported License. +http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/legalcode + +====================== +Multi image deployment +====================== + +https://blueprints.launchpad.net/bareon/+spec/multi-image-deployment + +Problem description +=================== + +Currently Bareon allows to deploy only one bootable image, other are 'utils' +images. It's impossible to deploy two images and switch between them. This blocks +a very useful use-case, where you can do a live update/modification of the system +with a downtime to one reboot only. + +Proposed change +=============== + +NOTE: This is a contribution of the feature developed within Cray OpenStack project. +We will try to make a minimum changes to existing code. + +Requirements: +- It should be possible to deploy multiple, co-resident images to a node. +- It should be possible to set the default boot partition of a node/instance. +- It should be possible to list valid bootable partitions. +- It should be possible to switch between valid bootable partitions on a node. + +The 'images' attribute of the provision.json schema in Ironic driver is extended +to the following: + + :: + + { + "images": [ + { + "name": "centos", + "boot": true, + "image_name": "centos-7.1.1503", + "image_uuid": "2a86b00d-cfa4-49d9-a008-13c7940ed02d", + "image_pull_url": "http://10.211.55.8:8080/v1/AUTH_319...", + "target": "/" + }, + { + "name": "ubuntu", + "boot": false, + "image_name": "ubuntu", + "image_uuid": "157636d8-62ad-499d-aecc-2ea4917ee396", + "image_pull_url": "http://10.211.55.8:8080/v1/AUTH_319...", + "target": "/" + } + ], + } + + +All the elements that have mount point in provision.json schema partitions +(e.g. *partition* and *lv*) are extended to include the new attribute **'images'**. +It will determine the set of images this partition belongs to. It is a list +value like ["os 1", "os 2"] that holds image names. In different OSs, +mount points may overlap. For example it will allow to define "/" for ["os 1"] +and "/" for ["os 2"], while allow them have the same "/usr/share/utils" +(e.g. ["os 1", "os 2"]). The attribute is optional, and by default the +partition belongs to the first image in deploy_config. Fstab is created basing on +this mapping as well. At the end, we will do a single grub install so it +takes all the available OSs and allow you to choose which one to boot. + +For example: + + :: + + "volumes": [ + { + "mount": "/", + "images": [ + "ubuntu 14.04" + ], + "type": "partition", + "file_system": "ext4", + "size": "4000" + }, + { + "mount": "/", + "images": [ + "centos 7.1" + ], + "type": "partition", + "file_system": "ext4", + "size": "5000" + }, + { + "mount": "/usr/share/common", + "images": [ + "centos 7.1", + "ubuntu 14.04" + ], + "type": "partition", + "file_system": "ext4", + "size": "10000" + } + + +Deploy flow: +------------ + +Schema passed to bareon will have one more implicit partition: +a partition with "mount": "multiboot" is a 100 Mb partition used for grub +installation. It is added to the first disk referenced in schema. It is not +mounted into the images. Instead grub.cfg there refers +kernels/ramdisks which reside at each image's boot dir. They are detected by +os-proper. The flow is the following: + +- Mount all partitions/lvs linked with "ubuntu 14.04" (/boot can't be separate + partition, otherwise will be skipped by os-prober). +- Deploy "ubuntu 14.04" (rsync or swift) +- Create fstab for "ubuntu 14.04" basing on partition<->image mapping +- Unmount all +- Mount all partitions/lvs linked with "centos 7.1" (/boot can't be separate + partition, otherwise will be skipped by os-prober). +- Deploy "centos 7.1" (rsync or swift) +- Create fstab for "centos 7.1" basing on partition<->image mapping. +- Unmount all +- Mount multiboot partition. +- Run grub install with os-prober +- Run grub mkconfig +- Unmount all +- Shut down the node. +- The disk where 'multiboot' partition resides is marked as bootable device in BIOS. +- Turn on the node. + +After the deployment, bareon will write found images to a separate file, +/tmp/boot-info.json. Example below: + + :: + + { + u'elements': [ + { + u'grub_id': 0, + u'image_name': u'centos-7.1.1503', + u'os_id': u'centos', + u'image_uuid': u'2a86b00d-cfa4-49d9-a008-13c7940ed02d', + u'boot_name': u'CentOSLinuxrelease7.1.1503(Core)(on/dev/vda3)', + u'root_uuid': u'2abf123d-d52f-4f62-a351-7358221bc51f' + }, + { + u'grub_id': 2, + u'image_name': u'ubuntu', + u'os_id': u'ubuntu', + u'image_uuid': u'157636d8-62ad-499d-aecc-2ea4917ee396', + u'boot_name': u'Ubuntu14.04.3LTS(14.04)(on/dev/vda4)', + u'root_uuid': u'688c5f1e-dc46-4aca-a90e-be21ba8aa3e2' + } + ], + u'current_element': 0, + u'multiboot_partition': u'3b360901-7896-48d4-a14d-fc35e1582c74' + } + +This json can be pulled out of the ramdisk and used for further management. +The multiboot_partition attribute holds a UUID of the implicit partition, where +grub.cfg is written. Any image can mount this partition and switch grub default +index, which will lead node to boot another image after the next power cycle. + +Alternatives +------------ + +None. + +Implementation +============== + +Assignee(s) +----------- + +- max_lobur + +Milestones +---------- + +See blueprint ref above. + +Work Items +---------- + +- rebase onto Bareon master. + +Dependencies +============ + +Code is rebased on the following patches: + +- Rsync image deployment +- Functional tests +- Split deploy driver +- Policy-based partitioning + +thus needs to be proposed after these. \ No newline at end of file